Defending People

the tao of criminal-defense trial lawyering

Mark’s Typical Trial Schedule

| June 30, 2010

(In lieu of the more com­plete trial jour­nal that I should have been keep­ing for the last eight week­days.) 0530: Get up. Pre­pare for trial. 0620: Break­fast, shower, shave, get dressed, etc. 0725: Leave for cour­t­house. 0800: Arrive in court­room. Med­i­tate. 0830: Trial begins. 0930: 1-hour break for court to han­dle court busi­ness. Small snack—half an […]

Share

Reptiles Revisited: Lizards Don’t Label [updated]

| March 2, 2010

It turns out that insur­ance defense lawyers are putting at least some effort into find­ing new ways to try cases. They have a mag­a­zine, For the Defense, and an asso­ci­ated blog (sadly uncommented-on). Kathy Cochran, writ­ing on the blog, takes note of David Ball and Don Keenan’s Rep­tile: This book posits that jurors must be […]

Share

The Anthony Graves Retrial Pregame Show

| February 12, 2010

In Anthony Graves’s first trial, pros­e­cu­tor Charles Sebesta had to cheat to win, hid­ing excul­pa­tory evi­dence and elic­it­ing per­jured tes­ti­mony (Graves v. Dretke, Fifth Cir­cuit opin­ion, PDF on Scribd). Now, not only has the evi­dence that Sebesta sup­pressed in vio­la­tion of Brady v. Mary­land been revealed so that the next pros­e­cu­tor try­ing the case can’t […]

Share

Punishing the Prosecutor to Fit the Crime

| February 12, 2010

A Har­ris County felony pros­e­cu­tor, in clos­ing argu­ment, says (PDF on Scribd): You-all heard some evi­dence, which I would have loved to brought you more peo­ple, but I couldn’t. This case is, does Har­ris County find what he did okay? And I still don’t know what he did, because he won’t even say it. We all […]

Share

Roeder, Padilla, Terry, Mohammed Part 1:Roeder

| February 3, 2010

On April 16th, 1995 (three days before the highly-significant-to-militias April 19th anniver­sary of the Okla­homa City Bomb­ing and the burn­ing of the Branch David­ian Com­pound in Waco), Scott Roeder was arrested with bomb-making mate­ri­als. Roeder claimed asso­ci­a­tion with the “Freemen” move­ment, yet another batch of per­sonal sov­er­eignty kooks. On May 31, 2009, Scott Roeder shot […]

Share

Read This Today

| February 3, 2010

In this morning’s Hous­ton Chron­i­cle, criminal-defense lawyer (and HCCLA ex-president, and for­mer U.S. Navy offi­cer) Pat McCann asks, Since When are Amer­i­cans Afraid of Tri­als? Those who are caught in the act of a crime or after­ward and can be pros­e­cuted in our jus­tice sys­tem, how­ever, should be pros­e­cuted. There is no sim­pler way to […]

Share

The Four Most Powerful Words in the Criminal Courthouse

| January 22, 2010

Try this: Stand up. Raise one foot off the ground. Now shift your weight for­ward. Don’t set your raised foot down. What hap­pens? You fall down. But if you do the same thing and set the raised foot down  to stop your fall, you take a step. Raise the other foot off the ground, shift your […]

Share

Case Oddity

| October 8, 2009

Here’s a pic­ture from Har­ris County’s 263rd Dis­trict Court yes­ter­day. The pros­e­cu­tors try­ing a mur­der (?) case had laid down a blue tape out­line of the dead person’s body, chalk-outline style, early in the trial: When I saw this, my first reac­tion was: awe­some! (coin­ci­den­tally, that was my nine-year-old’s reac­tion as well). The pros­e­cu­tors, Brad Hart […]

Share

In Support of the Nudge

| January 11, 2009

New York criminal-defense lawyer Scott Green­field and I usu­ally agree on things, and he’s a lot older and some­what wiser than me (though still spry), so when he seems to dis­agree with me I take a care­ful look to see if maybe I’m wrong. The client charged with a crime has three (in Texas, four) decisions […]

Share

Ladies of the Jury, Opposing Counsel is Just Like You … Except that She’s Much More Successful

| November 21, 2008

When I read arti­cles about quirks of human behav­ior, I try to think of how I can take advan­tage of them both defen­sively and offen­sively. For exam­ple, when I read an arti­cle (from the Amer­i­can Soci­ety of Trial Con­sul­tants’ The Jury Expert mag­a­zine) enti­tled How We Can Help Wit­nesses Remem­ber More, I con­sider not only […]

Share