Defending People

the tao of criminal-defense trial lawyering

Humpty Dumpty Hervey: Standard Written English = “Hyper-technical”

| April 15, 2011

This was the only ref­er­ence to time in the search-warrant affi­davit: In the past 72 hours, a con­fi­den­tial infor­mant advised the Affi­ant that Chris was seen in pos­ses­sion of a large amount of metham­phet­a­mine at his res­i­dence and busi­ness. The trial court and the Amar­illo Court of Appeals held that the war­rant was invalid because […]

Share

Partisan and Interested Magistrates?

| August 13, 2010

In regard to the search of a place, the United States Supreme Court has con­sis­tently favored the issuance of a war­rant by a neu­tral and detached judi­cial offi­cer as a more reli­able safe­guard against improper searches. See Lo-Ji Sales, Inc. v. New York, 442 U.S. 319, 326, 99 S.Ct. 2319, 2324, 60 L.Ed.2d 920 (1979). […]

Share

Boucher Revisited

| July 26, 2009

If I read The Volokh Con­spir­acy, I would’ve seen and (again) blogged about this back in Feb­ru­ary: U.S. Dis­trict Judge William K. Ses­sions III in Burling­ton handed down an opin­ion sort-of-reversing Mag­is­trate Judge Jerome J. Niedermeier’s order quash­ing a grand jury sub­poena for: all doc­u­ments, whether in elec­tronic or paper form, reflect­ing any pass­words used […]

Share

Arizona v. Gant

| April 21, 2009

Texas nar­cotics cops get an anony­mous tip that some­one is car­ry­ing drugs in his car. They call a cop in a marked unit to fol­low him. The uni­formed cop watches for a traf­fic vio­la­tion (chang­ing lanes with­out sig­nal­ing is pop­u­lar). The uni­formed cop stops the sus­pect, arrests him for the traf­fic vio­la­tion, cuffs and stuffs him, then […]

Share

Virginia v. Moore in Texas

| April 24, 2008

In Vir­ginia v. Moore the Supreme Court held that evi­dence is admis­si­ble under the Fourth Amend­ment even though obtained in a search inci­dent to an unlaw­ful arrest that was on prob­a­ble cause. In other words, if the state makes some­thing a non-arrestable crime (in Vir­ginia, dri­ving with a sus­pended license) and the police break state law […]

Share