Defending People

the tao of criminal-defense trial lawyering

SB 91">Reciprocal Discovery: Federal Rule 16 vs. Texas SB 91

| February 26, 2013

Grits for Break­fast asked, in a com­ment, “Do you find rec­i­p­ro­cal dis­cov­ery a hin­drance in your fed­eral cases? If not, what’s the dif­fer­ence?” Before I answer that, let me say that the fed­eral crim­i­nal jus­tice sys­tem should in no wise be con­sid­ered a model for other juris­dic­tions. Fed­eral court is a plea machine, in which […]

Share

SB 91—The Discovery Bill">Texas SB 91—The Discovery Bill

| February 24, 2013

Texas Sen­ate Bill 91 would pro­vide for for­mal dis­cov­ery in crim­i­nal cases, both from the State to the defense and from the defense to the State. Texas Defender Ser­vice, which lit­i­gates cap­i­tal cases, has come out in favor of this excres­cence. Their rea­son­ing is that, since there are Dis­trict Attor­neys who require waivers of Brady and other rights before they show […]

Share

Please Don’t Hesitate, Lady

| February 24, 2013

Accord­ing to Law Enforce­ment Tar­gets’ flacks,  I found while speak­ing with offi­cers and train­ers in the law enforce­ment com­mu­nity that there is a hes­i­ta­tion on the part of cops when deadly force is required on sub­jects with atyp­i­cal age, frailty or con­di­tion (one offi­cer explain­ing that he enlarged pho­tos of his own kids to use […]

Share

Cop’s Lawfare Fails

| February 12, 2013

Scott Green­field writes: [Y]ou have no idea how often some­one threat­ens a law­suit.  As a lawyer, I’m in a bet­ter sit­u­a­tion both to assess the merit of a claim, and if needed, to deal with it, than many other blog­gers. Oth­ers are not so for­tu­nate, lead­ing to the mis­guided sense that it’s the fault of […]

Share

This Guy Needs Me

| February 11, 2013

Andrew Sanchez III, 60, is set to be booked in Bexar County Jail on one count of improper pho­tog­ra­phy. A judge set bail at $7,500. Police said the offi­cer assigned to the Amer­i­can Cheer Power South­ern National Cham­pi­onship at the Alam­od­ome saw Sanchez video­tap­ing the per­form­ers around 11:30 a.m. Sun­day. The offi­cer ques­tioned Sanchez and […]

Share

¡SpiderOak, Sí. Dropbox, No!

| February 10, 2013

It is almost unfath­omable to me that a lawyer would give up con­fi­den­tial client infor­ma­tion with­out a fight. Yet Sam Glover at The Lawyerist sug­gests that this might be an option: “If you are the sort of per­son who would fight such a sub­poena, this would give you the option to do so.” The con­text: Glover is […]

Share

Revenge Porn and “Rape Culture” Culture

| February 10, 2013

Busi­ness Insider found some folks who see revenge porn not as a free-speech issue but as “a kind of high tech rape”: When we teach women not to walk alone in pub­lic after dark, not to wear par­tic­u­lar kinds of cloth­ing, not to engage in con­sen­sual acts like tak­ing nude pho­tos or mak­ing sex tapes, we’re […]

Share

Isn’t Revenge Porn Constitutionally Protected?

| February 9, 2013

Dylan Love at Busi­ness Insider (the arti­cle con­tains lots of bad legal advice) writes: There is a seedy under­belly of the inter­net where peo­ple post nude or oth­er­wise com­pro­mis­ing pho­tos of their ex-girlfriends or boyfriends for any­one to see, some­times to get back at a lover who jilted them. These so-called “revenge porn” sites bring up a […]

Share

Behind the Jury-Selection Curtain: Challenges for Cause

| February 9, 2013

A com­menter on this post asks: I do have a few ques­tions on chal­lenges for cause. Mostly, how are they resolved? Is it entirely about nego­ti­a­tion to con­sen­sus and good faith, or does the judge have com­plete dis­cre­tion? Also, what hap­pens if you don’t have a large enough panel remain­ing for a strike zone of […]

Share

Jury Selection Behind the Scenes

| February 8, 2013

Expe­ri­enced trial lawyers will often tell you that “jury selec­tion” is misnamed—it’s actu­ally jury deselec­tion.  Dif­fer­ent juris­dic­tions use dif­fer­ent meth­ods. In a Texas non-capital felony trial, the jury panel is ordi­nar­ily sixty peo­ple. Each juror is assigned a num­ber. The court brings the panel in to the court­room and lines them up on the benches in […]

Share