Defending People

the tao of criminal-defense trial lawyering

Peter A. Barone: Asshat Prosecutor of the Day

This came in today:

Hello to all,  

This is an announce­ment regard­ing ASA Peter A. Barone. On Jan­u­ary 7, 2013 Peter A. Barone fin­ished his final defense for his Ph.D. and was offi­cially announced as Dr. Peter A. Barone.

Dr. Barone spent 5+ years obtain­ing his degree and would like to request that dur­ing for­mal court pro­ceed­ings that you please refer to him by his proper and legal title, that being Dr. Barone. This request is sim­i­lar to the man­ner in which the sit­ting judge is called Judge or Your Honor, or as his fel­low attor­neys are addressed as coun­selor or Mr. or Ms., and not by their first name dur­ing for­mal proceedings. 

Dr. Barone would like to thank his fel­low col­leagues for their coop­er­a­tion in this mat­ter in advance and real­izes that at times it is dif­fi­cult to remem­ber a title change and is will­ing to assist by advis­ing and cor­rect­ing his col­leagues dur­ing offi­cial pro­ceed­ings of his new and per­ma­nent title if they inad­ver­tently forget.     

Vic­tor Garcia-Herreros
Legal Assis­tant for Dr. Peter Barone
State Attorney’s Office of High­lands County
411 S. Euca­lyp­tus Street
Sebring, FL 33870
(863)402‑6553
Fax: (863)402‑6563

Here, rife with gram­mat­i­cal errors, is Barone’s bio. Before he defended his dis­ser­ta­tion he was call­ing him­self “Pro­fes­sor PETER A. BARONE, ESQ., Ph.D.(c), LL.M, JD, MSMCPP.”

No self-respecting lawyer gives him­self the hon­orific “Esq.”; there is some­thing seri­ously wrong with a lawyer who not only insists on being called by an hon­orific that, out­side of the acad­emy, is tra­di­tion­ally reserved for physi­cians, but also will “assist by advis­ing and cor­rect­ing his [fel­low] col­leagues dur­ing offi­cial pro­ceed­ings of his new and per­ma­nent title if they inad­ver­tently forget.”

I could have great fun with this if he were in my jurisdiction.

Share

About The Author

Mark Bennett got his letter of marque from the Supreme Court of Texas in May 1995. He is famous for having no sense of humor when it comes to totalitarianism.

Comments

60 Responses to “Peter A. Barone: Asshat Prosecutor of the Day”

  1. Dr. Turk says:

    Since he already had a Juris Doc­tor, maybe he should ask to be called Dou­ble­Doc­tor Asshat.

  2. Robb Fickman says:

    I have never been to Sebring Florida but I would urge all there to call this guy by his given name
    ” Peter” which we all know is just another word for pecker.

  3. firehat says:

    He got his PhD from Inter­net col­lege, he has the auto­bi­o­graph­i­cal style of some­one who believes the Bushes are alien lizard-people, and he picked out the worst URL I’ve ever seen: http://professorpeterabaroneslawandcriminaljusticeconsulting.com/

    I may be most offended by that last one.

  4. now he’s going to have to reg­is­ter a new domain, doctorprofessorpeterabaroneslawandcriminaljusticeconsultingesquire.com

  5. Elizabeth Foley says:

    Yeah, the “Esq.” thing does tend to serve as a nice lit­tle warn­ing label.

    Nurse Barone, we really need to dis­cuss the…oh, that’s not it? Oops.”

  6. Ric Moore says:

    And half the folks in prison claim to be a painter. Things that make you go “Huh?” :) Ric

  7. Justin T. says:

    I say why not dou­ble down and get ordained online, and make every­one call him The Rev. Dr. Mas­ter Peter Barone, Esq.

  8. Mike Trent says:

    Are you sure his assis­tant really wrote that/sent it out? It looks like the kind of thing Mur­ray New­man used to write at the DA’s office when some­one unwisely left their com­puter unlocked…

  9. Def­i­nitely looks like a set-up. I’ll bet this pompous jerk [going by the bio] pissed some­one off enough to moti­vate them to send out a bogus announcement.

  10. Ron in Houston says:

    Actu­ally, I’ve met sev­eral Niger­ian lawyers that pre­fer the title Esquire. I don’t know if this is par­tic­u­larly rel­e­vant or not, but it is an obser­va­tion I’ve made.

    So, who gets to make the call whether some­one is a “self-respecting lawyer?”

  11. Jules Morrison says:

    He prob­a­bly doesn’t care about being polit­i­cally cor­rect, which is a seri­ous dis­ease right now in our great nation!

  12. Gideon says:

    Actu­ally, I’ve been on a years long cru­sade to get peo­ple to call me Doc­tor. I am a doc­tor, after all. A doc­tor of laws. YEAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHH.

  13. Mike Trent says:

    I am actu­ally going to legally change my first name to “Doc­tor”. Then you willl HAVE to call me that!!!

  14. Richard Albury says:

    He has an AOL email address, too…

    The domain was reg­is­tered 3 weeks after April 1st…

    Still smells like a hoax.

    Seems to be a real per­son, though:

    http://www.avvo.com/attorneys/33870-fl-peter-barone-1281026.html

  15. M. Stephenn Stanfield says:

    The elected state attor­ney for that cir­cuit is Jerry Hill. He know abouy the email; admits that it is gen­uine; and dread­fully embar­rassed by it.

    I sent Barone a con­grat­u­la­tory email address­ing him as ‘Pete.’

  16. I want to see him cor­rect a fed­eral judge in court. That would be awesome.

    I don’t even have the cuts to cor­rect them when they call me “Rushdie.”

    • Mark Bennett says:

      In my expe­ri­ence, fed­eral judges like lawyers with the back­bone to chal­lenge them. “It’s actu­ally ‘rush-ee,” your honor. ‘ROOSH-DEE’ is just my straw man.”

  17. Simon Elliott says:

    Why is a pros­e­cu­tor per­mit­ted to shill his legal and con­sult­ing ser­vices? My employer is a major law firm and would never per­mit me to do this.

    Also, his bio has a promi­nent pic­ture of New York. He is not licensed in NY, does not live in NY. Is this false adver­tis­ing? Is he ashamed of Florida?

  18. M. Stephen Stanfield says:

    Mr. Elliott, in Florida state employ­ees are per­mit­ted to have sec­ond jobs as long as they do not inter­fere with their state jobs.

    In my juris­dic­tion, the Eighth Cir­cuit, we have a pros­e­cu­tor who is also the head bar­tender at one of the most pop­u­lar bars in town that sits imme­di­ately across a major thor­ough from the Uni­ver­sity of Florida.

    • Simon Elliott says:

      Yes, and thats rea­son­able. Being a bar ten­der is not the sort of thing that would be likely to cause a con­flict of inter­est, unless you were on the liquor licens­ing board.

      Being a pros­e­cu­tor and con­sul­tant on all sorts of things: a lit­tle more difficult.

      Lets say want to knock out my com­peti­tor. I find some rea­son hire Barone as a “con­sul­tant” to see if he thinks that behav­ior X by my com­peti­tor is crim­i­nal. He con­cludes it is, and we see Barone brin­ing a crmi­inal case against my com­peti­tor. Barone can say he is just pros­e­cut­ing crime where he sees it.

      Tell me now that there is no con­flict of interest.

      • M. Stephen Stanfield says:

        Where did I write, “I approve and believe Barone’s side­line is okay?”

        Dude, learn to read.

  19. Think­ing out loud here… I’d prob­a­bly let him pull this schtick in front of the jury.

    Mr. Barone…“
    “Actu­ally, it’s DOCTOR Barone, coun­selor…“
    “Oh. Right. I’m sorry. Ladies, and gen­tle­men, I must apol­o­gize. Dr. Barone recently obtained his Ph.D. in (what­ever). He has asked that me and the court refer to him as doc­tor. If I acci­den­tally refer to him as “Mis­ter” or “Coun­selor” please assume that I meant Doc­tor. It’s my mistake.”

    Then con­tinue to call him “Mr. Barone” a few times and let him cor­rect you. The jury will love him.

    • Mark Bennett says:

      You’re not afraid to think out loud what every­body else is think­ing to him­self. That’s so adorable.

    • Theresa Mains says:

      that is hys­ter­i­cal!! per­fect for clos­ing argu­ments!! But isn’t call­ing oppos­ing coun­sel “dr” dis­tract­ing to the jury and the court? The “dr” part could be mis­con­strued as some more intel­li­gence, or exper­tise, or not.…, but the pro­ceed­ing has noth­ing to do w/ the CV of either attor­ney. One can’t say in open or close to the jury that they have a master’s or PHD in any­thing so a “Dr” title would be inad­ver­tently com­mu­ni­cat­ing that same infor­ma­tion, that is irrel­e­vant to the trial/hearing, to the jury. Wouldn’t a judge have dis­cre­tion to instruct both coun­sels that in the court­room their role is coun­selor rep­re­sent­ing the state/client and there­fore they are to be addressed as “coun­selor, “not Rev­erend, Doc­tor, Pro­fes­sor, or any other earned des­ig­na­tion, title, that is not part of the role in the court­room. Plus as one rep­re­sent­ing the state in pro­ceed­ings, the “dr” is not part of the rep­re­sen­ta­tion and the state should be able to tell this guy that any other des­ig­na­tions etc are not part of the representation.

  20. Jules Morrison says:

    I have to admit, it sounds a bit pompous, but you’ve got to give it to him, he had the guts to make such a demand!

  21. M. Stephen Stanfield says:

    The chief admin­is­tra­tive assis­tant state attor­ney in that office, Bryan Haas, has already stated that Barone will not be addressed as Dr.

    Barone though, in an email he sent me just this morn­ing, is refer­ring to him­self as Dr.

    So what­ever hap­pens should be very entertaining.

  22. Thomas Ross says:

    Appar­ently he’s a secret agent too. So that’s 007 Dr. Barone to you.

  23. Jack Wilkins says:

    I called the 10th Cir­cuit State Attor­neys Office and they con­firmed it was not a prank and he would NOT be called doctor.

  24. Bill Poser says:

    One would think that some­one who writes and speaks for a liv­ing and has received so many degrees would know such things as how to break a text into paragraphs.

  25. Bob Brandon says:

    What’s his Ph.D in? Advanced cra­nial recititis?

  26. Speak­ing as a Ph.D. holder, I know Pete Barone is an ass­hat! Indeed, posts like this are why I don’t drink (any­thing at all) and surf the Inter­net at the same time.

    Like sev­eral other com­menters here, I won­dered if that announce­ment was a prank.

    Bill Poser: You learn how to break text into para­graphs in ele­men­tary school. You then unlearn it in grad­u­ate school. (And if you’re lucky and/or some­what con­sid­er­ate, you re-learn it in the worka­day world.)

    Jeff Deutsch

  27. Ron in Houston says:

    Mark — more of this, please? You’re blog is always inter­est­ing, but the LOL poten­tial of this post has just been price­less. Kudos to your damn witty peo­ple that comment.

  28. Rolando says:

    Is Barone’s degree from this online program?

    http://www.capella.edu/online-degrees/phd-criminal-justice/

  29. Andrew Fine says:

    You are all just jeal­ous. There isn’t a sin­gle Doc­tor / super spy / pro­fes­sor / lawyer / cer­ti­fied mas­sage ther­a­pist / among you plebes. I’ll have you know these titles and hon­orifics don’t come easy. I sent $30 to the Uni­ver­sal Life Church. I taught some col­lege classes. I went to law school. I got appointed to some sort of amor­phous fac­ulty posi­tion in a pri­mar­ily French speak­ing juris­dic­tion. I got my face painted and rode on an ele­phant at age 5. What have YOU done???

    Respect­fully,

    Rev­erend Pro­fes­sor J. A. Fine, Esq., J.D., M.C., King of the Cir­cus (1976)

  30. Jennifer Davis says:

    This is by far the most hilar­i­ous blog I have read yet. I truly don’t under­stand how you a “Reli­gious” Attor­ney with only a BA and JD can down grade another Attor­ney that has by far more edu­ca­tion and expe­ri­ence then you. Based on the infor­ma­tion you posted regard­ing Peter A Barone it is sad to say but YOU ARE JEALOUS!!

    PS, by the way, before I com­mented I made sure to research you and Peter A Barone. If any­one is inter­ested in read­ing the true facts this is the web­site with the cor­rect infor­ma­tion.
    http://WWW.Professorpeterabaroneslawandcriminaljusticeconsulting.com
    *Let the facts speak for itself…

  31. Mike Trent says:

    It is indeed hilar­i­ous, but per­haps not in the way that Peter (and) Jen­nifer think. Was “reli­gious” put in quotes to denote sar­casm, or is he really that stu­pid? –Never mind.…dumb question.

    • Jennifer Davis says:

      Mike you are as pathetic as mark.I am not one to judge but where in your Reli­gion study or right mind do you think it is ok to post somthing about some­one in pub­lic that you have clue about…“ARE YOU REALLY THAT STUPID?-NEVER MINDDUMB QUESTION” now that was a denote sarcasm!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  32. Andrew Fine says:

    Appar­ently in all that police train­ing Barone didn’t learn any­thing about Word­Press, com­ments, and IP addresses. He should ask for a full tuition refund.

  33. Since I won my fan­tasy foot­ball league this year, I want to be addressed as “Champ”.

  34. Ron in Houston says:

    Dear Mark:

    I love you. Well, at least in a man hug sort of way.

    Ron

  35. AC says:

    Is Dr. also a gen­er­ally accepted abbre­vi­a­tion for ‘douche’ ?

  36. Bergman Oswell says:

    Sounds like the lead-in to a joke, kinda…

    Doc Doc”

  37. Tanner Andrews says:

    In some states, the bar rules will not let a lawyer call him­self “doc­tor” unless he is also a med­ical doc­tor. Just saying.

Leave a non-anonymous Reply