Defending People

the tao of criminal-defense trial lawyering

What’s an Onlya?

A cou­ple of peo­ple have asked me, “what’s an onlya”?

An onlya is any per­son whom a group has a rea­son to mar­gin­al­ize: “he’s only a drug user,” “he’s only a kid,” “she’s only a judge.”

Mem­bers of the group can treat the onlya worse than they would treat other group members.

We’re all onlyas to someone.

Whether some­one is an onlya depends on the group. Among drug users, a drug user is not an onlya. 

So Felix Booker, Dr. Michael LaPaglia’s first doc­u­mented vic­tim, might have been an onlya to LaPaglia because he had been arrested and was sus­pected of pos­sess­ing drugs: only a crim­i­nal. He is an onlya to the courts because LaPaglia found drugs.

But Dr. LaPaglia’s sec­ond doc­u­mented vic­tim, Antwan Gul­ley, isn’t an onlya to the civil courts because LaPaglia didn’t find drugs in his rectum.

It’s not right, of course, for the civil jus­tice sys­tem to treat Mr. Booker dif­fer­ently than Mr. Gul­ley: LaPaglia com­mit­ted the same torts on both men. But there you go.

Share

About The Author

Mark Bennett got his letter of marque from the Supreme Court of Texas in May 1995. He is famous for having no sense of humor when it comes to totalitarianism.

Comments

One Response to “What’s an Onlya?”

  1. Mike Paar says:

    Check your email.

Leave a non-anonymous Reply